Telecom Operators Earn More As Nigerians Battle Poor Network Service

… Network Speeds Stagnate As Higher Tariffs Expose Regulatory Weakness
In January 2025, fifteen months into Dr Aminu Maida’s tenure, the Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC) approved a 50 per cent rise in telecom tariffs, the first major adjustment in more than a decade. Subscribers got something back in April 2026, when the NCC’s compensation framework took effect. Two Airtel subscribers who shared their credits with THE WHISTLER received ₦261 and ₦99.
That sequence runs through the records THE WHISTLER reviewed: a price increase that took effect within three weeks, and protection for the people paying it that arrived later, smaller and harder to measure.
The Commission says about 75 million subscribers have been compensated for poor service. It has not published what the compensation was worth, which operators breached standards or what penalties followed. The only penalty itemised is ₦45 million, against ₦12.4 billion in liabilities the NCC said in January 2026 were moving through regulatory processing.
Operators profited out of the arrangement. MTN’s and Airtel’s combined revenue per user rose 31.6 per cent in the second quarter of 2025. Subscribers saw the national median download speed slip from 20.1 megabits per second to 19.8 Mbps between August 2025 and February 2026, and the NCC’s data records 558,546 complaints against the four mobile operators in the first nine months of 2026.
The market did grow under Maida. Nigeria added more than 31 million broadband subscriptions between December 2023 and August 2026, and the NCC says operators invested more than ₦2.5 trillion in 2025. That progress is real, and this report sets it out.
A Price Rise First, Protection Later
The NCC approved tariff adjustments of up to 50 per cent on January 20, 2025. It said some operators had asked for more than 100 per cent, and that its decision weighed industry sustainability against consumer protection. It told operators to apply the new rates transparently, simplify their tariff structures and offer plans suited to different income levels. The floor price of a call rose from ₦6.40 to ₦9.60 a minute, SMS from ₦4 to ₦6 and a gigabyte of data from ₦287.50 to ₦431.25.
Subscriber groups objected. The National Association of Telecommunications Subscribers (NATCOMS) said it would challenge the increase in court, and the Nigeria Labour Congress (NLC) threatened industrial action. On February 3, the Federal Government and the NLC set up a 10-member committee to review the increase.
Operators did not wait for it. MTN’s new prices took effect on February 10, and other networks followed. NATCOMS asked the NCC on February 13 to sanction operators that had started early; THE WHISTLER found no public record of a sanction. On February 21, the committee agreed to cut the increase from 50 per cent to 35 per cent. News report on March 27 said operators had kept the full 50 per cent in their rates and that neither the Federal Government nor the NCC had announced the reduction. The material reviewed contains no later announcement of a cut.
The NCC’s account is that it capped the increase at half of what operators wanted, and Maida says tariffs remain low by global standards. The sequence still matters. The increase reached subscribers within weeks, but the mechanism to compensate them for poor service took 15 months to appear.
What Subscribers Pay Now
Prices moved faster than the NCC’s approval implied. On February 11, 2025, MTN raised its 15GB weekly bundle from ₦2,000 to ₦6,000, an increase of 200 per cent against the 50 per cent the NCC had approved. MTN apologised two days later, called the change a mistake and reversed it. Arise reported that the company then listed a 15GB bundle at ₦6,500 as a monthly plan.
A BusinessDay survey of published rates found that the average price of 1GB across MTN, Airtel, Globacom and 9mobile rose 65.22 per cent after the increase, from ₦287.50 to ₦475. Airtel’s 1GB plan went from ₦350 to ₦500 and MTN’s from ₦200 to ₦350. Airtel moved to a flat call rate of 25 kobo a second, about ₦15 a minute against ₦11 before, according to TechCabal. Maida said in August 2025 that call rates stood at about ₦18 to ₦19 a minute, against ₦15 in the early 2000s.
Small buyers pay more per unit. An analysis report seen by THE WHISTLER found that daily data plans, the only entry point for the lowest-income subscribers, cost three to five times more per megabyte than weekly or monthly bundles.
Spending is easier to measure than service. Applying an estimated price of about ₦800 per gigabyte to the NCC’s consumption figures, news reports put subscribers’ spending on data at ₦3.33 trillion in the first three months of 2026. Volume grew too. The National Bureau of Statistics put telecommunications’ real contribution to GDP, which strips out price changes, at ₦5.2 trillion in the second quarter of 2026, against about ₦4.7 trillion a year earlier. Subscribers are paying more and using more. None of the figures reviewed shows how much of the extra spending bought better service and how much simply paid higher prices.
None of the figures reviewed shows how much of subscribers’ higher spending bought more or better service, and how much simply paid higher prices.
Network Quality: Paying More, Getting Little
The NCC said operators were expected to demonstrate measurable service improvements in return for the increase. THE WHISTLER examined the NCC’s network-performance assessments comparing August 2025 with February 2026. National median download speed fell from 20.1 Mbps to 19.8 Mbps. Median upload speed rose from 9.5 Mbps to 9.8 Mbps. Game latency improved from 35 milliseconds to 32 milliseconds, jitter fell by 12.5 per cent, and video and web-browsing scores improved.
The results are mixed, and they do not show that the tariff increase caused any of the changes. They also do not show the improvement the increase was meant to buy. The NCC’s May 2026 summary said median download speed had risen from 16.5 Mbps to 20 Mbps since January 2024. Set beside the August 2025 reading of 20.1 Mbps, that suggests most of the gain came before August 2025, with little movement since. The statement did not say which measurement produced the 16.5 Mbps starting point.
An NCC capacity analysis comparing September 2025 with February 2026 found that the share of tested urban areas with capacity limitations increased for MTN, Airtel and Globacom. MTN’s share rose from 4 per cent to 6.7 per cent, Airtel’s from 2 per cent to 2.6 per cent and Globacom’s from 1.3 per cent to 2.8 per cent.
The report identified pressure in high-density areas, including parts of Lagos and Abuja. It defines a zone as constrained where daytime speed is less than half the night-time speed, and it excludes areas with too few tests.
Independent testing shows a wide spread between operators. Opensignal’s July 2026 report, based on tests between April 1 and June 29, put download speed experience at 21.3 Mbps for MTN, 17.6 Mbps for T2mobile, 14.2 Mbps for Airtel and 13.0 Mbps for Globacom. MTN won 11 of the report’s 12 awards. Those tests use a different method from the NCC’s and cannot be added to its figures, but they show that the operator a subscriber uses matters as much as where the subscriber lives.
Operators say demand is the problem. THE WHISTLER spoke to Gbenga Adebayo, Chairman of the Association of Licensed Telecoms Operators of Nigeria (ALTON), who said operators were expanding capacity but rising data consumption was quickly absorbing the additions.
The NCC reported that data consumption rose from about 1.13 million terabytes in July 2025 to 1.66 million terabytes in July 2026, an increase of nearly 47 per cent.
“As we are deploying more capacity, it is consumed,” Adebayo said, describing network expansion as “work in progress.” He also pointed to power supply, vandalism and damage to fibre cables, and said operators were working with regulators and the Federal Ministry of Works on an arrangement to give notice before roadworks that could damage fibre.
The Guardian reported a year after the increase that Maida had admitted telephone services had not been optimal and had said 2026 would bring consequences for operators. NCC is yet published what those consequences were.
Complaints Galore With Thin Remedy
The NCC’s monthly complaint data for January to September 2026 records 558,546 complaints against the four mobile network operators. Airtel accounts for 327,808, MTN for 157,092, Globacom for 68,683 and T2mobile for 4,963. T2mobile has no entries for August and September, so its figure covers seven months and the overall count is slightly understated.
Airtel stands out. It holds about 34 per cent of the four operators’ subscribers but accounted for about 59 per cent of the complaints, or 486 complaints for every 100,000 subscribers, against 153 for MTN, 292 for Globacom and 138 for T2mobile. The subscriber figures in the dataset are undated and sum to 197 million, close to the NCC’s August 2026 total, and the rates are THE WHISTLER’s calculations.
The NCC says complaints are falling. But data shows the fall is uneven across operators. In April 2026, it said monthly complaints had dropped from about 351,000 in January 2025, when the tariff adjustment was approved, to 76,000 in March 2026. The monthly data shows the total falling from 86,370 in January 2026 to 40,296 in September, but unevenly: Globacom’s monthly count fell by about 75 per cent and MTN’s by about 65 per cent, while Airtel’s fell by about 36 per cent.
THE WHISTLER spoke to Nigerians in urban and rural areas, and some described poor service from their network providers. Their accounts are individual experiences, not measurements.
Makuochukwu Udeh runs a point-of-sale (POS) business in Abakpa Nike, Enugu. She said unstable connectivity often holds up her work.
“At times, my customers are frustrated and leave because of delay in completing their transactions due to poor network, thereby making me to lose my income,” she said.
She said she loads enough credit to cover a day’s business, but the credit does not last. The NCC’s own assessment put mobile-payment success at 94 per cent in urban areas and 71 per cent in rural ones, so even in a city about one attempt in 17 fails.
“In fact, sometimes I will think it is because my credit is low, I will go load more credit but the problem will persist, especially during the raining season,” she said.
Umar, who lives in Minna, Niger State, said call quality is the problem. “When you make a call, it has too much background noise and cracking that you could barely have a clean and clear line for conversation,” he said. “This makes you keep on shouting during conversations that ordinarily should be in a low tone.”
The remedy the NCC offers is the compensation framework, which took effect in April 2026 and covers qualifying service failures from November 2025. Under it, eligible subscribers in affected local government areas can receive airtime credits where an operator fails prescribed network-performance standards. Eligibility depends on the conditions the Commission set, including verified poor service and a qualifying revenue-generating event.
Subscriber messages reviewed by THE WHISTLER show that at least some customers have received credits. Two Airtel subscribers shared messages stating that their accounts had been credited “in line with NCC Directive” for network failures between February and April 2026.
One message, dated September 23, stated that ₦261 had been credited; another, dated October 31, stated that ₦99 had been credited.
The NCC says the reach is wide. Maida told the 95th Telecom Consumers Parliament in Lagos on October 20 that about 75 million subscribers had received airtime or data compensation between November 2025 and September 2026, and that nearly three million had received refunds for failed airtime and data transactions.
The Commission also said it had carried out more than 6,500 network improvement activities in 2026. It gave no naira value for the compensation, no breakdown by operator and no definition of an improvement activity.
The 75 million figure is not new. A communiqué issued after the NCC’s 109th board meeting on May 25 said operators had compensated more than 75 million subscribers. That first round, paid from late April, covered service failures between November 2025 and January 2026, and the NCC said later periods would be processed after validation.
The October figure, “about 75 million”, covers a period several months longer. Either the count stopped growing or the Commission is repeating an estimate; the published material does not say which. Against the NCC’s count of 192.23 million active subscriptions in June 2026, 75 million is about 39 per cent, though subscriptions are not the same as individual subscribers.
Maida himself acknowledged the limits of the remedy at the October consumer parliament. Compensation, he said, “cannot recover a lost business opportunity”, or a conversation that could not take place, and the Commission’s priority remained reducing the failures that make it necessary.
For a POS operator like Udeh, whose customers walk away when a transfer will not go through, that is the gap. An airtime credit of ₦99 or ₦261 does not replace a lost sale. The test of the framework is whether failures are becoming less frequent, and the NCC has not published data that would show it.
Sanctions: ₦45 million Against ₦12.4 billion
On sanctions, the picture is thin. In January 2026, the NCC said that breaches carrying cumulative liabilities of about ₦12.4 billion were moving through regulatory processing, with pre-enforcement notices already issued.
That is a potential liability, not money collected. The only penalty itemised was a combined ₦45 million imposed on Globacom, Airtel and IHS Towers in October 2025, about 0.4 per cent of the ₦12.4 billion by THE WHISTLER’s calculation.
The Commission also said it was updating its Enforcement Processes Regulations so that sanctions keep their deterrent effect, and that capital spending by operators would not by itself excuse poor performance. The material reviewed does not show whether any of the ₦12.4 billion has since been imposed or collected.
The framework provides for independent audits, and in June the NCC board said it was independently validating operators’ claims. THE WHISTLER found no published result of either. Nor does the material reviewed show how many Local Government Areas qualified for compensation, the total value of credits or which operators breached the standards.
A complete assessment of enforcement needs an operator-by-operator record of formal warnings, compliance directives, fines, repeat breaches and corrective actions. The NCC has not published one. It would be wrong to infer that no action was taken. The question is whether the Commission can show the record, and show that corrective measures produced verified improvement.
Data depletion, billing and identity risks
Data depletion was the only complaint category the first-half reports broke out. It accounted for 23,396 complaints: MTN 12,212, Airtel 9,806, Globacom 1,373 and T2mobile five. The figures reviewed give no counts for billing, failed payments, top-up problems, number portability, value-added services or SIM-related complaints, and no data on how long cases took to close.
Maida told the 93rd Telecom Consumers Parliament in November 2024 that data depletion and billing top complaints because tariffs and billing are complex.
The NCC’s public guidance in August 2025 was a list of nine tips for subscribers on managing their data, including data-saving modes and rollover. In May 2026, operators were preparing data calculators to address depletion complaints. The guidance puts the burden of managing data on the subscriber.
The NCC’s newer tools follow the same pattern, announcements without published outcomes. At its September 9 meeting, the board said the Device Management System, which checks phones against type-approval rules and allows stolen devices to be blocked across networks, was live.
It said the Telecommunications Identity Risk Management System (TIRMS), meant to let banks and other authorised institutions check whether a number has been recycled, swapped or barred, would go live in October 2026. The board also raised concern about a resurgence of call masking, in which international calls are disguised as local ones, and restated its zero-tolerance position.
These measures bear on whether subscribers can trust the network with their money and identity, not only whether it connects. THE WHISTLER found no published data on devices blocked, on whether TIRMS went live as scheduled or which institutions use it, or on action taken over call masking.
Connectivity: Who Is Left Behind
An NCC comparative assessment of network quality and user experience reports marked differences between urban and rural areas. It recorded average web-page loading times of 2.1 seconds in urban locations and 5.4 seconds in rural locations.
Video-streaming success was 91.5 per cent in urban areas and 64.2 per cent in rural areas. Mobile-payment success was 94 per cent in urban areas, compared with 71 per cent in rural locations.
The same assessment showed differences between states. Lagos recorded a performance index of 0.84, while Taraba scored 0.39, Yobe 0.35 and Zamfara 0.31. These are the report’s own index values, not a ranking of every subscriber’s personal experience. They show how a national average can conceal large geographic differences.
A separate NCC connectivity report comparing September 2025 with March 2026 recorded some improvement in rural performance. Median rural download speed rose from 15.0 Mbps to 16.4 Mbps, median rural upload speed from 6.1 Mbps to 9.0 Mbps, and rural latency improved from 37 milliseconds to 34 milliseconds. The urban-rural divide is still significant.
Almost all of the growth is on mobile networks. Fixed broadband, which carries the heavier data loads of homes, businesses, schools and offices, remains small.
At an industry forum on fibre-to-the-home in Lagos at the end of June 2026, Maida said Nigeria had only about 265,000 active fibre-to-the-home (FTTH) subscriptions. Two months later, the country had 126.2 million broadband subscriptions, more than 470 for every FTTH connection.
The NCC’s quarterly figures show fibre growing from that low base. Its Q3 2026 data, as analysed by Technext24, put fibre-to-the-x (FTTX) subscriptions at about 401,700, with MTN alone holding 242,916, or roughly 60 per cent.
The FTTH and FTTX figures measure different things and should not be read as a growth rate, but both point to the same imbalance. Right-of-way delays and fibre cuts have been cited as major obstacles, and the NCC has not published specific measures or a timeline for closing the gap.
In February 2025, the NCC reported more than 50,000 fibre-cut incidents in the preceding year, about 30,000 of which it attributed to federal and state road construction, and announced a joint standing committee with relevant ministries.
In May 2026, it put avoidable incidents in 2025 at more than 27,000. In August 2026, it reported more than 5,000 in the first six months of the year. The three figures cover different periods and may not use the same definitions, so they cannot show a rise or fall. The NCC says the committee has since been expanded to include the Office of the National Security Adviser. Fibre cuts are not all attributable to the regulator or operators, but the response to recurring disruption is part of the sector’s resilience test.
Lawmakers and The FCCPC Step In
Lawmakers have taken up the complaints. In May 2026, the House of Representatives criticised the NCC for what members described as complacency and weak oversight, and resolved to set up an ad hoc committee on poor telecom service.
On October 21, that committee, chaired by Olumide Osoba, gave MTN, Airtel, Globacom, Mafab Communications and other operators seven days to explain why poor service persists, and summoned their chief executives with a warning that any who stayed away could face arrest summonses.
The committee noted that MTN and Mafab had not honoured earlier invitations. It directed the NCC to ensure the operators complied.
The appearance, first fixed for October 28, was pushed to November 4 after the committee rejected a request from ALTON chairman Gbenga Adebayo to represent the operators. Lawmakers said each operator holds its own NCC licence and must answer for its own performance.
The chief executives did not turn up on November 4. ALTON representatives attended instead and said the operators had started legal proceedings challenging the summons. The committee sent them out, saying its invitations were addressed to individual companies and not to the association, and warned that further unauthorised appearances could draw sanctions.
The Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (FCCPC) also has a consumer-protection role. It opened an inquiry into MTN in December 2024 over unresolved complaints of undelivered data, unexplained data depletion and inadequate customer support, with hearings scheduled for December 3 to 5 that year.
In February 2025, the Federal High Court in Lagos held, according to an FCCPC statement, that the FCCPC and the NCC share concurrent jurisdiction over competition and consumer protection in telecoms, and that the FCCPC’s summons to MTN was lawful.
THE WHISTLER has requested the inquiry’s outcome, telecom complaint figures and details of FCCPC’s work with the NCC. The Commission’s response was awaited at the time of filing.
Where the NCC Can Point To Progress
The NCC’s industry statistics, updated on October 12, 2026, put broadband subscriptions at 94,757,184 in December 2023, 112,665,176 in December 2025 and 126,217,174 in August 2026. That is an increase of 31,459,990 subscriptions between December 2023 and August 2026, and penetration rose from 43.71 per cent to 58.22 per cent.
The growth still missed the 70 per cent penetration target set for the end of 2025. The NCC’s published figure for December 2025 was 51.97 per cent, a shortfall of 18.03 percentage points. The NCC’s subscription and penetration figures imply a population base of about 216.8 million (THE WHISTLER’s calculation).
On that base, 70 per cent equals about 151.8 million subscriptions, leaving a gap of roughly 25.5 million from the August 2026 total. Subscriptions grew by about 1.7 million a month between December 2025 and August 2026, so at that pace the gap would take around 15 months to close. That is arithmetic, not a forecast. Penetration here also counts subscriptions, not people, and one person may hold more than one.
Investment is the strongest part of the record. The NCC said in May 2026 that mobile network operators invested more than ₦2.13 trillion in 2025 and tower companies a further ₦373.8 billion, a combined total of more than ₦2.5 trillion.
By the NCC board’s 110th meeting on September 9, operators had deployed 8,526 of 12,179 committed coverage and capacity sites, about 70 per cent, up from roughly 5,000 reported at the board’s May meeting. The NCC also said more than 730 additional 5G sites had been deployed across 27 states, and that 4G penetration had risen from 45 per cent to 54 per cent since January 2024.
THE WHISTLER contacted MTN Nigeria, the country’s largest mobile network operator by subscriber base, to establish the specific investments it had made following the January 2025 approval. In response, the company shared its MIP Alumni H1 2026 report.
According to the report, MTN Nigeria spent ₦620.5 billion on capital expenditure, excluding leases, between January and June 2026. Full-year capex was ₦1.003 trillion in 2025, against ₦388.2 billion in 2024 and ₦403.2 billion in 2023. MTN said the money went to congestion relief, radio-network densification, new sites and a new data centre.
These figures show scale. They do not show where the sites are, how many are new rather than upgrades, how many carry commercial traffic, or what subscribers noticed as a result. Rural performance did improve in some measures, as the connectivity figures above show, and complaints did fall. The compensation framework is also a step toward the protection the NCC promised, even if its results are unpublished.
Cheap on Paper
Nigeria remains inexpensive for mobile data by international comparison. The GSMA put the average cost at $0.38 per gigabyte and the World Broadband Price League 2026 ranked Nigeria 49th among 214 countries for the lowest broadband costs, as the Guardian reported. Maida made the same case in August 2025.
That comparison is the strongest defence of the NCC’s tariff decision. It also measures price, not protection. A cheap gigabyte that depletes unexpectedly, drops a call or fails to complete a transfer costs a subscriber more than its sticker price. It should be noted that where nominal prices look low, affordability measured against income can still be a challenge.
No Response From Operators
THE WHISTLER put the complaint figures and related questions to Airtel Nigeria. Femi Adeniran, the company’s Director of Corporate Communications and CSR, declined to comment on matters involving the regulator. He said regulated companies generally avoid public comment on their regulators, and advised THE WHISTLER to rely on data the NCC publishes itself.
THE WHISTLER contacted Nnenna Ukoha, the NCC’s Director of Public Affairs, on WhatsApp on October 10, 2026, seeking an interview or clarifications on broadband targets, tariff-related service improvements, network performance, fibre cuts, consumer compensation, complaints, enforcement and coordination with the FCCPC. Repeated phone calls went unanswered. As at the time of filing this report, the Commission had not responded.
The Commission’s response is important to interpreting these findings, particularly where public documents leave gaps about target definitions, methodology, compensation outcomes and enforcement. THE WHISTLER will update the report if the Commission provides relevant information.
The Test Ahead
Maida’s tenure has coincided with a substantial increase in broadband subscriptions, data consumption and operator investment. It has also coincided with a price increase that reached subscribers within weeks, a service that the NCC’s own speed measurements show barely moved, 558,546 complaints in nine months and a remedy whose value the NCC has not disclosed.
The NCC’s account is that monthly complaints have fallen sharply, 75 million subscribers have been compensated and more than 6,500 network improvements have been made. The public records support part of that account and leave the rest unverified. They do not establish that the January 2025 tariff increase caused any improvement, and they do not show what the compensation was worth, how many operators breached standards or what penalties followed.
The clearest test of the regulator’s performance is whether it can show, with comparable and transparent data, where networks improved, where service remains weak, how complaints were resolved and what happened when operators breached standards. Lawmakers are now putting those questions to the operators directly.
For subscribers who were asked to pay more, the central question remains straightforward: what improved, where did it improve, and how can consumers verify that they are getting the service they pay for?



